Over and over again it has been demonstrated that the whole can be greater than the sum of its parts, that good people from diverse fields working together can make major scientific discoveries that are denied geniuses working in isolation.”
Kurt Vonnegut address to the APS, trascription curtesy Panagiota Papakonstantinou ADDRESS TO THE APS.pdf (135.8 KB)
Younger scientists are extremely sensitive to the moral implications of all they do. My fictitious old-time scientist asked, among other things, this question: “What is sin?” He asked that question mockingly as though the concept of sin were as obsolete as plate armor. Young scientists, it seems to me, are fascinated by the idea of sin. They perceive it as anything
human that seriously threatens the planet and the life thereon.
[…]
If Professor Norwood really is a humanistic physicist, then he is exactly my idea of what a virtuous physicist should be. A virtuous physicist is a humanistic physicist. Being a humanistic physicist, incidentally, is a good way to get two Nobel Prizes instead of one. What does a humanistic physicist do? Why, he watches people, listens to them, thinks about them, wishes them and their planet well. He wouldn’t knowingly hurt people. He wouldn’t knowingly
help politicians or soldiers hurt people. If he comes across a technique that would obviously hurt people, he keeps it to himself. He knows that a scientist can be an accessory to murder most foul. That’s simple enough, surely. That’s surely clear.
[…]
I don’t find this particularly congenial, moralizing up here. Moralizing hasn’t really been my style up to now. But people, university people in particular, seem to be demanding more and more that persons who lecture to them put morals at the end of their lectures.
This letter helped me to see that Dr. Fieser and other old-fashioned scientists like him were and are as innocent as Adam and Eve. There was nothing at all sinful in Dr. Fieser’s creation of napalm. Scientists will never be so innocent again. Any young scientist, by contrast, when asked by the military to create a terror weapon on the order of napalm, is bound to suspect that he may be committing modern sin. God bless him for that.